We do not know exactly what happened, but the police were called by Theo’s bio-grandmother at the end of December 2022 or beginning of January 2023, claiming domestic abuse by her partner. She had thrown all his belongings out of the apartment onto the lawn and told him to go. Unbeknownst to us, this was the second time the police had been called to their residence for domestic abuse and reports filed; all this while Theo was there with them. His grandma was actually the one who called us to get Theo before the police arrived, so we rushed to their apartment. Talk about déjà vu; we had experienced this with Theo’s bio-mom a year prior to this. The biggest difference was that CPS was not there yet to take Theo away.
We were able to remove Theo from the scene and keep him with us since we had already been approved by CPS. We figured we would just have him until everything was sorted out, but the case took on a more serious note. Due to this being the second call to the police for domestic violence, Grandma lost her kinship rights to care for Theo. So, on January 10, 2023, Theo was placed back in Denyse’s care on the grounds of emergency custody, and he has been with us full-time since that date.
A temporary custody hearing was scheduled for March 13, 2023, and Denyse was awarded temporary custody of Theo, which is slightly different than kinship custody. Kinship custody refers to the care of a child by a relative or close family friend, while temporary custody refers to any short-term court-ordered custody arrangement that can be granted to relatives, non-relatives, or child welfare agencies. At this point, we hoped things were moving in our favor, but the pressure, the fear, and the concerns ramped up because the stakes had gotten higher.
Theo’s family was out of control. They were no longer playing nice or able to hold up the facade that they were good, stable, and loving people. However, it was not an automatic win for us; we still had to walk through the painstaking steps of this process. Theo’s bio-mom was still in the game and now with a vengeance, and she still had an opportunity to be reunified with Theo.
CPS approved supervised family visits at this time. The plan was that Denyse could decide the when and where, and, as long as she was present, there were no restrictions, which is putting a lot on a person. I thought it placed Denyse in a vulnerable position, so I made myself available for these visits, which I did not like. Denyse, of course, said she could manage it without me and that it wasn’t that big of a deal, but it was to me. We had always made a concerted effort to keep peace with Theo’s bio-family, mostly for his sake, but it was becoming more difficult. We went into this arrangement with our eyes wide open, never leaving our backs exposed.
We would meet them in the park for play dates, we allowed them to spend time with Theo at church, and we invited them to take part in his life celebrations, but they always went too far with things. The church visits started to get out of hand because they would invite all kinds of people (cousins, friends, significant others, and so on) to come to church during our services to see and play with Theo. It was a revolving door, very disorderly and distracting.
We have a room in the back of the church that we pretty much made a family visitation room. We truly tried to be accommodating, but it became somewhat of a free-for-all, and they started to disrupt the worship services and make the parishioners uncomfortable. They were loud, disrespectful, and were not there for the right reasons. People were coming in who were not even supposed to be around Theo. We showed a lot of grace, and I probably let this go on too long. I was just trying to make it all work, but it came at a price.
When Theo’s bio-mom brought the third man of hers into the church, a man who had just got out of prison after an extended sentence, things began to get worse. They were definitely toxic together. They began using together, and the domestic violence from both parties got out of hand and carried over into the church. I finally had to ask the family to find another church to attend because ours was being taken advantage of by them, and my requests for changed behavior had been ignored.
That was only the second time in my 25+ years of pastoring that I had to ask someone to leave the church, but it was in the best interest of the rest of my flock. I really struggled with this, but I know I heard from God to take this position, which eased the pain a little. Bio-mom was irate at me and used it to attack my character publicly: “How can somebody who calls themselves a pastor kick people who need them out of a church?” “What kind of pastor does this to somebody who is just trying to spend time with her child?” Her goal was to get sympathy, and she achieved this on some level. She spewed a lot of venom at me regarding my stance on this decision, but I never turned back. I could not allow the house of the Lord to continue being disrespected.
There were so many injustices about our situation that I struggled to make peace with. For example, why would someone who continued to live in the darkness have another opportunity to have this child of light back in their life? It is hard to accept things when they seem unfair. I had really cared about Theo’s bio-mom and wanted her to turn her life around, to do good, and to be a good mother. I had deep compassion for her because the odds had been stacked against her since birth; however, I was losing those feelings, and they were being replaced by feelings that were not nearly as godlike. This was a personal struggle that I had to hash out with the Lord daily.
I did not want anything bad to happen to her; I just wanted the madness to end, for her to go away. I struggled with loving her at this point. I was wearing down and losing faith – not in God or our beautiful, little, non-traditional family unit, but in the system and in people. I did not understand why the process had to be so difficult. It seemed like a no-brainer to me, but there was a protocol that legally had to be followed.
The thousands of other people, whether kin or foster parents, riding out this grueling process know what I am talking about. You not only fall in love with a child, but you know what might await them if they are returned to their biological family. You believe you can give them a better life, but they may not get that chance. It is so disheartening, but you carry on, and you love every minute you get to spend with this gift currently in your care. You take the small wins.
On September 23, 2023, we were able to celebrate Theo’s 3rd birthday with him. We partied at our friends’ house with a wiener roast and toast to the cutest, coolest kid on the block, at least we all thought he was. I tried my hardest not to focus on the fear that this could be the last birthday party we had with him, and I immersed myself in the love of family and friends who gathered in honor of Theo that day. He had become the love of so many lives – beautiful, good people who cared deeply for him. It blessed me that he had so much support and a great connection to amazing people. This celebration has become a family tradition, and in a few short weeks from when I am writing this, we will be celebrating his 6th birthday around that same campfire ring. God is so good.
We tried to keep Theo’s life as normal as possible. He was doing so well with Help Me Grow that they thought he was ready for pre-school, so we enrolled him in Discovery Center, which was one of the greatest blessings of Theo’s young life. I was so torn about him starting school so young, but Denyse knew it was the right thing to do for him. He was petrified to leave Denyse; he had been with her 24/7 for nine months straight.
I remember him screaming his head off because he did not want to go into the building, but she was firm with him, and she let them take him because she knew this was going to be good for him. I was traumatized; yes, the drama queen came out. I held it inside, but it physically shook me. When I love, I love hard, and I wear it on my sleeve, in Theo’s case, both sleeves and both pant legs. Denyse was so strong. When God told her to do something, she never hesitated or questioned it. I truly respect that about her.
It did not take Theo long to test out of his IEP (Individualized Education Plan), and he grew leaps and bounds. His speech accelerated, his communication improved, and his social interactions with those outside his circle began developing. He never had trouble with comprehension. He is a very smart child, a little too insightful at times, but I also know part of that is his spiritual giftings. Discovery Center, the administration, the teachers, the aides, and the specialists all have a very special place in my heart. They were an integral part of Theo’s growth as a student and a person.
Things turned ugly after Grandma lost her rights to keep Theo, and the bio-family realized that the tide was no longer rolling in their favor. As stated before, they were done playing nice. They turned on us in a very dark, disturbing way. They thought they could manipulate Denyse, but she was not intimidated by them. She was going to abide by the rules and not give them special, unsanctioned access to Theo, like sneaking them onto the campus of the Discovery Center so they could be present for Theo’s first day of preschool. The audacity of some of their requests exasperated me. These were the kinds of ridiculous requests they made to Denyse.
It made them so angry when she denied them. She did not make the rules, but they took it out on her. They had lost those rights, and, on top of that, they continued exhibiting unacceptable behavior, and the deck was stacked against them. We did not do any of this; they did. It became more important now than ever to protect Theo from the crazy that was about to become even weirder and more bizarre.